Monday, June 20, 2011

On Jewish National Identity: A Response to Daniel Gordis and Yitzhak Adlerstein


Daniel Gordis' observations concerning the alienation of non-Orthodox rabbinical students have elicited a thoughtful response by Yitzhak Adlerstein. He advises against Orthodox triumphalism, out of a serious concern for the Jewish collective. I support his sentiments as far as they go. They do not, however, go far enough. For, as far as real concern and identification with Israel is concerned, American Orthodoxy has much with which to be concerned.

I left the following comment, which I hope to expand later:

Overall, I agree with your reaction to Gordis’ piece and with the overall tenor of the comments (except for the first, which I think is reprehensible). I would only add a further reason for caution, lest we pat ourselves on the back overly much.

I have just completed a four month sabbatical in the US. One thing that struck me was how incredibly self-satisfied large swaths of American Orthodox Jews appear to be. For many of the people I met (though assuredly not the majority, I hope), Israel is a place to visit, without really engaging or encountering it; to use, without internalizing; to pine for in low keys on Tisha B’Av, without putting Aliyah on the agenda. One indicator of this attenuation of relations is the Hebrew illiteracy (both in speaking and writing) that marks the overwhelming majority of Orthodox Jews (including rabbis and Lamdanim). Without a common language, how can there be a common cause?

So, while we share the secret of our blessed solidarity and sense of peoplehood with other Jews, it behooves the Diaspora Jewish Community to check itself, as well.

To his credit, R. Adlerstein's response to my remarks (in a private note) were both open and appreciative.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

american orthodoxy is self-satisfied, even smug, with reference to israel, there i agree with you. the lack of hebrew knowlegde is a symptom of this, and a crime and scandal of jewish education.
but when did jews ever have a common language? certainly not for thousands of years...

Anonymous said...

"hebrew knowlegde is a symptom of this, and a crime and scandal of jewish education.
but when did jews ever have a common language? certainly not for thousands of years..."

Why is lack of Hebrew knowledge a crime if lack of common language has been true for at least 2500 years?
Hebrew skills can found in Arab chavrei knesset, PLO executives etc-it is far from being a Jewish language today-most Jews can't understand it-and a high percentage of those who speak it are not Jewish.
BTW written by a former Massad counsellor