Sunday, May 07, 2006

More Jews Live in Eretz Yisrael

This is a subject I've long thought about, but first a word from Charles Krauthammer:

The Washington Post
May 5, 2006
Never Again?
By Charles Krauthammer


WHEN SOMETHING HAPPENS for the first time in 1,871 years, it is worth noting. In A.D. 70, and again in 135, the Roman Empire brutally put down Jewish revolts in Judea, destroying Jerusalem, killing hundreds of thousands of Jews and sending hundreds of thousands more into slavery and exile. For nearly two millennia, the Jews wandered the world. And now, in 2006, for the first time since then, there are once again more Jews living in Israel -- the successor state to Judea -- than in any other place on Earth.

Israel's Jewish population has just passed 5.6 million. America's Jewish population was about 5.5 million in 1990, dropped to about 5.2 million 10 years later and is in a precipitous decline that, because of low fertility rates and high levels of assimilation, will cut that number in half by mid-century.When 6 million European Jews were killed in the Holocaust, only two main centers of Jewish life remained: America and Israel.

That binary star system remains today, but a tipping point has just been reached. With every year, as the Jewish population continues to rise in Israel and decline in America (and in the rest of the Diaspora), Israel increasingly becomes, as it was at the time of Jesus, the center of the Jewish world.

An epic restoration, and one of the most improbable. To take just one of the remarkable achievements of the return: Hebrew is the only "dead" language in recorded history to have been brought back to daily use as the living language of a nation. But there is a price and a danger to this transformation. It radically alters the prospects for Jewish survival.

For 2,000 years, Jews found protection in dispersion -- protection not for individual communities, which were routinely persecuted and massacred, but protection for the Jewish people as a whole. Decimated here, they could survive there. They could be persecuted in Spain and find refuge in Constantinople. They could be massacred in the Rhineland during the Crusades or in the Ukraine during the Khmelnytsky Insurrection of 1648-49 and yet survive in the rest of Europe.Hitler put an end to that illusion. He demonstrated that modern anti-Semitism married to modern technology -- railroads, disciplined bureaucracies, gas chambers that kill with industrial efficiency -- could take a scattered people and "concentrate" them for annihilation.

The establishment of Israel was a Jewish declaration to a world that had allowed the Holocaust to happen -- after Hitler had made his intentions perfectly clear -- that the Jews would henceforth resort to self-protection and self-reliance. And so they have, building a Jewish army, the first in 2,000 years, that prevailed in three great wars of survival (1948-49, 1967 and 1973).

But in a cruel historical irony, doing so required concentration -- putting all the eggs back in one basket, a tiny territory hard by the Mediterranean, eight miles wide at its waist. A tempting target for those who would finish Hitler's work.

His successors now reside in Tehran. The world has paid ample attention to President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's declaration that Israel must be destroyed. Less attention has been paid to Iranian leaders' pronouncements on exactly how Israel would be "eliminated by one storm," as Ahmadinejad has promised.

Former president Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani, the presumed moderate of this gang, has explained that "the use of a nuclear bomb in Israel will leave nothing on the ground, whereas it will only damage the world of Islam." The logic is impeccable, the intention clear: A nuclear attack would effectively destroy tiny Israel, while any retaliation launched by a dying Israel would have no major effect on an Islamic civilization of a billion people stretching from Mauritania to Indonesia.

As it races to acquire nuclear weapons, Iran makes clear that if there is any trouble, the Jews will be the first to suffer. "We have announced that wherever [in Iran] America does make any mischief, the first place we target will be Israel," said Gen. Mohammad Ebrahim Dehghani, a top Revolutionary Guards commander. Hitler was only slightly more direct when he announced seven months before invading Poland that, if there was another war, "the result will be . . . the annihilation of the Jewish race in Europe."

Last week Bernard Lewis, America's dean of Islamic studies, who just turned 90 and remembers the 20th century well, confessed that for the first time he feels it is 1938 again. He did not need to add that in 1938, in the face of the gathering storm -- a fanatical, aggressive, openly declared enemy of the West, and most determinedly of the Jews -- the world did nothing.

When Iran's mullahs acquire their coveted nukes in the next few years, the number of Jews in Israel will just be reaching 6 million. Never again?


treppenwitz said...

Wow! This is some of your best writing (and thinking).

While many of us were slapping each other on the back and exchanging high fives over the whole population thing, I don't think too many of us gave a moment's thought about the chilling 'other side of the coin'.

Thanks for putting this in perspective.

Jeffrey said...

I wish I could take credit, but that needs to go to Dr. Charles Krauthammer.

halivni said...


If I am not mistaken, the population milestone will take on halakhic significance as well once we pass the 50% mark for world Jewry - rov yisrael shruyin b'artzan

thanbo said...

Does this mean "yisrael shruyin al admatam" and the Yovel cycle should start up again?

Will we soon see a "heter yovel"?

Anonymous said...

Yovel will not be the biggest 'problem.'
The laws of Eretz Yisrael which right now are rabbinic in nature -- terumah, ma'asar, shemitta, etc. -- will take on biblical proportions, which will render many loopholes and leniencies we routinely use moot.
Some possible delaying tactics of this situation: there are still more Jews outside than inside of Israel (there are Diaspora Jews who do not live in the US), or perhaps we can get off the hook because the Jews do not live in their proper tribal lands (this is mentioned in the sources).

This makes the (in)famous R. Chaim ha-Kohen on the sugya of yishuv EY in the end of Kesubos all the more cogent.

Are our rabbis, and are we, up to the challenge?

Ben Bayit said...

The "high concentration" argument is one that is often heard from Haredi non or antizionist circles. Hungarian Chassidim as well as Yekke Torah Im Derech Eretz types. However, the Iranian threat, coupled with the pronouncement of the Nobel Prize winning Professor of Game Theory Aumann that "he is worried that perhaps Satmar was correct" should give one pause for thought.

Over 40 years ago Norman Lamm wrote an article in Traditon on Satmar's ideology which he laughed off as being a ridiculous curiosity, essentially an historical footnote. I think the jury is stil out on that one - even if the 70,000 Satmars in the world split into two or more chatzerot.

Ben said...

I hate to nitpick when our very survival is at stake but your title is misleading. Israeli Jews now constitute a plurality of world Jewry but not a majority.

Jeffrey said...